Lizzie Borden

1860-1927

Despite the nursery rhyme, Lizzie Borden was acquitted of the 1892 hatchet murders of her father and stepmother because the men on the jury could not believe that such a proper young lady would do such terrible things.

Aside from the victims, only two people were at home during the murders, Lizzie Borden and the maid, Brigette Sullivan, and most writers have assumed that one or the other of them did it. Of those two, Lizzie acted the most suspiciously, such as trying to buy poison before, burning a stained dress afterward, and showing less shock and anguish than one might expect when one's family is murdered in the next room.

The two murders were an hour and a half apart, so that kind of rules out a wandering stranger who would have to hide somewhere in the house without killing Lizzie or Brigette and hope no one discovered the first murder before he struck again. Then he'd have to escape down the street drenched in blood.

No one else was ever charged in the murders because the authorities were sure they got it right the first time.

How lesbian was she?  We've got two suspects: Lizzie Borden and Brigette Sullivan. Instead of either/or, why not both? Of course cooperating and keeping it secret would require a strong bond between them, so ... lesbian lovers? And maybe the reason investigators never found clothes soaked in blood is because they did their killing naked.

Just imagine it. I'll give you a few minutes.

More convincingly: Later in life Lizzie became close friends with the actress Nance O'Neil. We don't know what was going on, but Lizzie followed her like a groupie, threw lavish parties for Nance and her troupe and paid Nance’s legal expenses in contractual disputes with theater owners.

SITE INDEX